Ethical Decision Making Meets the Real World of Field Work - kovntikis.cf

 

social work ethics case studies

very useful in teaching about social work ethics. The three case studies are particularly helpful in a course on social work values and ethics. The examples raise many ethical issues, value conflicts, and dilemmas that can be discussed in an ethics course. Some of the major themes revolve around confidentiality with issues of cultural. National Association of Social Workers (). Code of ethics. Washington, D.C.: Author. Marian Mattison, DSW, ACSW, is an Associate Professor and Chair of the Department of Social Work at Providence College in Providence, RI. She has conducted numerous workshops on the subject of ethical decision making and has written articles on this subject. This makes social work ethical dilemma case studies relevant topic for research. Conducting such a work may help to develop unified values and attitudes for both the social worker and the client, taking into account the specific features of a certain mentality.A case study on ethical dilemma allows talking about the following situations.


Social Work Ethics: 5 Common Dilemmas and How to Handle Them Responsibly | kovntikis.cf


The Smiths-A Rural Family. Like this article? Share it! As you began your internship, you had been initially prepared through foundation courses that social work ethics case studies you with the skills and knowledge necessary for successful interventions with clients.

While the curriculum prepares students for entry level practice, a great deal of incidental learning takes place as students gain experience with actual clients. This holds particularly true as it relates to negotiating the ethical aspects of social work practice. While no course of study can fully prepare students to anticipate every ethical dilemma they may encounter, students are instructed to be aware of their limitations and to rely on supervision in cases where experience may help them to determine the best interests of clients.

Social workers, both inexperienced and experienced, can prepare themselves to address and resolve ethical dilemmas by sharpening their awareness of the ethical standards meant to guide practice as detailed in the NASW Code of Ethics and that serve as the basis against which the behavior of the social worker will be judged in cases of ethical misconduct.

Developing one' ability for ethical reasoning can help prevent errors in judgment and forestall charges of ethical misconduct and will result in better service to clients. What follows is an ethical dilemma faced by a student intern who unintentionally acquires information about social work ethics case studies client during the course of the field seminar.

Read the following case and give some thought to the dimensions of the ethical dilemma and how you, as the social worker, would decide what action to take. Julia is a social work intern placed at a local Family Services Agency. Over the course of the last six months, she has worked with Carla Rodriguez to reunify her with her three children, ages 11, 4, and 3.

Carla social work ethics case studies 28 is the mother of Tatiana age 11Derrick age 4and Angel age 3. The children were removed to foster care when charges of neglect were substantiated.

Derrick and Angel were placed in separate foster homes, and Tatiana stayed with Carla' sister. Carla' drug addiction limited her ability to care for her children, who were found to be living in squalid conditions.

While the children were in foster care, Carla made a concerted effort to have the children returned to her care. The children were reunified with their mother two months ago. Carla has been drug free for a number of months and is meeting the minimum standards of care for her children. In the field internship seminar, social work interns were exchanging information about their cases. An intern placed in a local junior high school asked her peers for advice about the group she is running.

Julia, social work ethics case studies, the intern working at the Family Services site, realizes that the client being described is the daughter of her client, Carla. Julia has no firsthand evidence to suggest that Carla is using drugs. Julia wonders what to do with this information. There are many questions for Julia to consider as she decides how to use the information she has just acquired.

The following are questions that social workers might raise in resolving this ethical dilemma and determining what action to take. Do you believe that Julia is obligated to report Carla' drug use, and if so, to whom should this report social work ethics case studies made?

Julia must be clear about which client she owes primary responsibility to. If her obligation is to protect the children, social work ethics case studies, she might feel more compelled to report Carla' drug use, as it social work ethics case studies involve the children' safety. The social worker' beliefs about family unity and social work ethics case studies local foster care system are also factors that will influence the decision to act.

Is the risk to the children greater if the family unity is again disrupted? Are the same foster homes still available? Could the disruption caused by foster care possibly be greater than the consequences of Carla' recreational drug use? These are just some of the questions raised by this ethical dilemma; you may have identified others.

Julia may worry that if she confronts Carla with the information about her drug use, Carla will deny the allegation and the relationship will be irreparably damaged.

If the client demands to know the source of the information, should Julia indicate that it actually came from her daughter in the course of a group counseling session? What are the consequences and risks of this disclosure for Tatiana?

Should the year-old be placed in this position? Imagine the anger that Tatiana might have for a social worker who uses the information she disclosed in confidence against her family.

Use social work ethics case studies a framework for analyzing ethical dilemmas is highly recommended. Decision-making models have been presented in greater detail elsewhere and space restrictions prevent a detailed review of these here.

See, for example, Mattison, M. Ethical decision making: The person in the process. Social Work, 45 3 One begins to address the ethical dilemma by identifying those professional values or obligations that conflict and explicating the conflicts of interest.

Can the social worker justify setting limits on Carla' right to self-determine based on the belief that the well-being of her children is being harmed by her marijuana use? Knowing one' ethical obligations in advance of ethical conflicts may prevent ethical misconduct.

For example, as interns, did the students alert their clients to the fact that they are interns-in-training and that they would be discussing case material with supervisors and peers see NASW Code of Ethics, Standards 1. Had the instructor of the seminar cautioned students about the potential issues surrounding breaches of client confidentiality and ideas to best manage violations should they occur see NASW Code of Ethics, Standard 3.

Would she have disclosed so openly if she had anticipated the consequences of her disclosure? Competent practice dictates that social workers routinely document their efforts to use supervision and note their efforts to carefully analyze the ethical dilemma and their relationship to it.

In addressing ethical dilemmas, social workers often fail to acknowledge and accept that personal values, life experiences, and unaccounted for influences personal, cultural, religious beliefs and preferences do affect professional decisions.

Social workers must be willing to identify these influences and the role they play in selecting a choice of action. For example, Julia' personal beliefs about marijuana use will influence her decision about reporting. Julia may equate marijuana use with alcohol consumption and may not consider there to be any special risk to the children caused by Carla' use of it.

How do individual states define neglect related to drug use? Does parental use of marijuana itself constitute neglect, or are other indicators that the parent is unable to properly care for the children required? What are the social worker' legal obligations as a mandated reporter? The social worker must consider the possible consequences of his or her actions for each person who may potentially be harmed or benefit by the action chosen.

Is the intern working with Tatiana at the junior high school obligated to tell Tatiana that the information she shared in confidence in the group will be brought to the attention of her mother' social worker see NASW Code of Ethics, Standard 1. Is she obligated to disclose the details of how this occurred? Can Tatiana be expected to trust social workers in the future? In practice classes, students often learn that there is typically a preferred skill, practice approach, or model to apply based on case circumstances.

The relative certainty of practice decisions feels safer than the uncertainty of struggling with and resolving ethical dilemmas. Becoming accustomed to the uncertainties associated with resolving ethical dilemmas is a target that many social workers fail to strike, social work ethics case studies. This involves a process of deconstruction and contemplation that enables you to consciously articulate the reasoning behind your choice of action. You must be able to explain and justify that the decision you reached protected the client' rights and served the client' best interests, and that you upheld the values and standards of the profession.

This case example is presented to stimulate interest in the subject of ethical decision making and is designed to encourage students and new social workers to discuss and debate ethical dilemmas with peers and colleagues. Finding out what others think or would do in a case such as this will help you to clarify your position and will sharpen your ethical reasoning skills. Discuss this case or another ethical dilemma you are facing in your practice at the lunch table, social work ethics case studies, bring it into the classroom for discussion, or deliberate on it in a supervisory session.

Ask questions, reach to see social work ethics case studies through the lens of others who have a stake in the outcome of the decision, social work ethics case studies, and be open to the positions and value preferences of colleagues. As social workers, we are in close agreement about upholding standards related to client confidentiality, fostering self-determination, promoting the dignity and worth of the client, social work ethics case studies, and acting in a trustworthy manner with clients, social work ethics case studies.

There is less agreement about how to translate these into practice, particularly when one of these commitments can be served only at the expense of another. National Association of Social Workers Code of ethics. Washington, D. She has conducted numerous workshops on the subject of ethical decision making and social work ethics case studies written articles on this subject. All rights reserved, social work ethics case studies. BoxHarrisburg, PAor at linda. All material published on this website Copyright White Hat Communications.

Please contact the publisher for permission to reproduce or reprint any materials on this site. Skip to main content. About Us Advertise Subscribe Now. Follow us! Back to Search Results. The Dilemma What follows is an ethical dilemma faced by a student intern who unintentionally acquires information about her client during the course of the field seminar.

The Questions There are many questions for Julia to consider as she decides how to use the information she has just acquired. The Right Decision? Reference National Association of Social Workers Tags Spring Current Issue in Print.

 

Cases - Ethics Unwrapped

 

social work ethics case studies

 

This makes social work ethical dilemma case studies relevant topic for research. Conducting such a work may help to develop unified values and attitudes for both the social worker and the client, taking into account the specific features of a certain mentality.A case study on ethical dilemma allows talking about the following situations. Ethics: To Tell or Not to Tell-A Case Study. by Lee J. Zook, Ph.D. Some years ago, prior to teaching in undergraduate social work, I was working with families and children in an outpatient psychiatric setting, Children' Agency. In the previous year, I had completed my MSW, having practiced social work several years with an undergraduate degree. Social Work Ethics: 5 Common Dilemmas and How to Handle Them Responsibly The National Association of Social Workers (NASW) Code of Ethics is a set of guiding principles to assist social workers in making decisions in the best interests of their clients, even if they might contradict what we might do in our personal lives.